First results of the art critique streams! (+TIER feedback wanted!)
Added 2023-11-21 18:21:27 +0000 UTCTHE STARS ARE ALIGNED SORRY FOR THE DELAY I FINALLY REMEMBERED TO POST AT A DECENT HOUR!!!
Before I say anything else, please don't offer any further critique of the art above in the comments UNLESS the artist comments asking for it! I was very careful to try and give each artist the feedback they specifically wanted, let's respect that!
So here's the results of the first test art critique livestreams! In order of original piece -> my adjustments piece -> my adjustments and so on and so on! The first 4 were done in the first stream, the 5th was split between the first and second stream, and the last 3 were done in the second stream! You can watch those again here if you'd like to hear how I talked through my thought process! https://youtube.com/live/YtpSTJI9ST8 https://youtube.com/live/cqzzk9yYM7Q
We tried to adopt a system where we only briefly went over the pieces of artists who weren't in the chat at the time, and I'm including the psd and clip files of all my edits which include the layers of my changes and any of the studies I might've done based on the artists inspiration list to help me adjust their piece to their taste!
I believe we are going to do this again next month! We're going to create a new google form with updated questions to help the critique process, expect that sometime early next month!
If anyone who attended the stream has any feedback for how we can better host them in the future, that's something I'd love to hear! And for full transparency, the current idea behind these streams is that we may want to open a new tier for patreon in 2024 that would be higher than the $10 tier (currently we're thinking somewhere between $15 and $25), other hypothetical plans for that new tier include being able to submit for ocs to be potentially redesigned by me in a future video series, and maybe even a monthly podcast from my team! Any ideas of feedback on the ideas for this new tier are 100% welcome!
Comments
Omg hi hello!! Please feel free to submit another piece for the next round! We kept it brief with your piece since you weren’t there and we didn’t ask enough questions in the forms, but generally we really liked your piece! The character designs are great : )
June
2023-11-23 18:50:47 +0000 UTCI DIDN’T MAKE IT FOR THE CRITIQUE UGHHHH, THANK YOU FOR CRITIQUING MY STUFF HOWEVER, I was the deception of stars cover 💜💜💜
2023-11-23 12:24:55 +0000 UTCWould absolutely want to do this again! 💜💜 These are my possible suggestions/ideas for future streams if you’d think they be helpful!: - Given the range of possibly doing $15-$25 for the tier, I’d say $20 is a good middle ground for the tier’s price! - This was an idea I pitched to Robyn last stream, but possibly making a separate chat room/channel in the Patreon section of the server for the artist you’re currently critiquing (if they’re present) so you don’t have to scavenge for their messages in the YT stream chat and see them easier (if it’s doable!) - I think depending on if the person is or isn’t present for the stream you could possibly set some sort of time limit on how much time you spend on each piece (if the artist is not present, then around 30-45 minutes, and if they are, possibly around 45-60 minutes). And if an artist wasn’t present the last stream when their art was critique, you can spend an extra 15-20 minutes if you have any additional critiques or questions for them! Love y’all sm!!! Looking forward to December’s streams and hoping my art piece gets picked in one of them! :>>
GeoDraws
2023-11-22 00:36:42 +0000 UTC
